13. Progress in SSRL Operations
by Piero Pianetta
Appendix B Self-Evaluation FY2006
Return to Table of
Contents
FY2006 User Experimental Run
In the FY2006 user run, the facility proved to be
exceptionally reliable, providing very stable beam for a
very high fraction (96.2%) of the scheduled time. This
is an exceptional achievement for a new storage ring.
The user run commenced on November 28, 2005 and
continued through August 7, 2006, and the SPEAR3 storage
ring operated at 3 GeV/100 mA and provided 60+ hour life
times. (The average uptime over the past five years was
96%.) During the FY2006 run, scientists on 345 different
proposals received beam time in a total of 1,002
experimental starts involving approximately 1,700 users,
with approximately 900 users on-site or remote accessing
beam line equipment. Approximately 66% of the users came
from universities and other laboratories in the United
States, 15% from DOE and US government laboratories, 5%
from US industry, and 14% from international
institutions.
Distribution of Proposals Receiving Beam:
Materials Science 14%
Physics 5%
Chemistry 16%
Polymers
2%
Medical Applications 5%
Biology/Life Sciences 45%
Earth Sciences 3%
Environmental Sciences 5%
Optics 1%
Engineering 3%
Other 1%
SPEAR3 Accelerator Improvements
The accelerator improvements for SPEAR3 are focused in
four areas: 1) characterizing and improving accelerator
performance and reliability at 100 mA to maximize beam
quality for users; 2) developing and implementing a new
lattice optics configuration that accommodates a
magnetic chicane having two small vertical beam size
waists (the double-waist chicane optics, or DWC optics)
in the east long straight section; 3) characterizing and
optimizing accelerator operation at 500 mA; and 4)
preparing for the implementation of top-off injection
with beam line stoppers open.
Injector –
Work continued in FY2006 to improve the reliability and
operation of the injector at 3 GeV. The injection timing
system was modified to equalize booster ramping
efficiency for all bucket timings. Work continued to
characterize and stabilize gun and linac operation. A
feedback system was implemented to stabilize the booster
White Circuit. Booster performance was assessed and
plans for its realignment were made. A study of the
stability of all injector power supply systems was
initiated. Additional improvements include rebuilding
the BTS injection line (to remove several vacuum
windows), upgrading transport line beam position and
intensity monitors, enhancing the stability and
monitoring of powered devices, completing a pulsed
signal monitoring system, implementing an EPICS control
system access to injector component control and readback
variables, and installing a second klystron for the
gun/linac system. The design of simpler and more robust
booster kicker pulsers has begun and plans for
developing a laser-heated-cathode rf gun are in
progress. The Accelerator Physics group is studying
booster beam capture efficiency and has proposed a minor
lattice modification that could improve performance.
Studies of other booster improvements, including the
powering of unused sextupole magnets and the possible
addition of a subharmonic rf cavity, are under way. The
injector improvement project will continue in FY2007 and
beyond.
Turn-Turn Beam Position Monitors (BPMs) –
Commissioning and development of the user software
interface for the turn-turn BPM system is continuing in
FY2006. The test tone calibration system will be
commissioned and the true performance of the processors
is being quantified. The turn-turn BPMs will then be
integrated into the orbit feedback system.
Synchrotron Light Monitor (SLM)
–
The SLM beam line received first light in January 2006.
The optical bench components were commissioned and the
beam line component alignment was refined. The first
measurement of beam bunch length was performed during
the user run and low alpha experiments were performed in
which the bunch length was shorted to 6.5 ps with 100 mA
stored current in SPEAR. The upgrade and realignment of
the BL2 pinhole camera system was completed in early
spring of 2006.
Beam Scrapers
–
The new horizontal and vertical beam scrapers were
commissioned and used to characterize beam lifetime,
injection apertures, and minimum apertures for future
insertion devices. The scrapers will continue to be a
valuable diagnostic for beam size, lifetime and aperture
studies.
LION Development –
Commissioning of the Long Ion Chamber (LION) system
continued during the FY2006 user run. Tests of the
system with high injected beam current were carried out
in early spring 2006. The LION system must be connected
to the Beam Containment System before the injected beam
current limit can be raised to enable faster 500-mA fill
times.
High-Current SPEAR3 Tests – SSRL received authorization from the DOE Site Office to
conduct SPEAR3 operation with currents up to 500 mA,
above the official safety envelope value of 100 mA
allowing routine running of SPEAR3 with beam lines
closed for accelerator studies. A successful test of the
Double Waist Chicane lattice (see below) at 500 mA was
conducted in February 2006 with no observed problems.
Orbit Control
– The first phase of the fast orbit feedback system,
using only the 54 Bergoz averaged-orbit BPMs, was
completed. A test of the system demonstrated successful
feedback operation with a bandwidth approaching 100 Hz.
Further work was done to optimize the SVD-derived
inverse response matrix and digital filters as well as
to maximize the frequency response
of the orbit corrector power supplies. Work continued in
order to provide an operator interface anddata
acquisition applications for the new fast orbit feedback
system.
The orbit monitor processing system has a temperature
dependence that has been demonstrated to cause orbit
instability when the feedback system is active. A
project to build temperature-controlled rooms and
install finer temperature regulation in the processor
equipment racks was completed in time for testing before
the end of the run. Initial tests showed that the
cooling system reduced the processor temperature
variation from several degrees Celsius to less than a
degree, thus decreasing the processor
temperature-related orbit instability. Further tests
during the 2007 run will quantify the degree of
improvement.
Hydrostatic level sensors (HLS) were installed a few
strategic areas in the SPEAR3 tunnel to monitor the
vertical motion of tunnel floor and some beam line
components. If this system proves to be useful for
detecting component motion, more sensors will be added
in the future and their signals will be used in the
orbit feedback system.
Double Waist Chicane (DWC) Lattice
– The DWC optics, temporarily installed without chicane
magnets during the FY2005 shutdown, was tested
successfully for the first time in December 2005. While
the lifetime was a few percent less than that for the
normal lattice, this was anticipated in the optics
studies and is acceptable. This lattice was
characterized and optimized so that it will be used with
the new BL12 undulator and beam line which was installed
during the 2006 summer shutdown. It has already been
demonstrated to work without problems at 500 mA and with
the “dispersion leak” optics variation that reduces the
emittance from 18 nm-rad to 12 nm-rad. The design and
fabrication of vacuum chamber and chicane magnets needed
for the full DWC implementation are being completed
during the 2006 shutdown. Most of the components have
been installed, together with the BL12 in-vacuum
undulator. The installation of the beam line that
utilize the downstream chicane straight section is
underway.
Top-Off Injection –
The design of the system needed for top-off injection
with beam line stoppers open was begun in FY2006. This
injection mode, with minimal interruption to users, will
enable more frequent beam injection to limit beam
current variation, minimizing the variation of thermal
power on beam line optical components and improving beam
stability for users. Work has begun to improve the
injector systems to accomplish this injection mode (see
above). An extensive study of beam loss modes was
initiated to determine what radiation safety components
will be required to inject beam into SPEAR3 with open
beam line radiation stoppers. Significant changes to the
Personnel Protection System, including the Septum
Interlock, will be needed to implement the top-off
system. This work will enable the first phase of top-off
injection - a mode that will maintain beam current
constancy in SPEAR3 to a few percent. A second phase of
top-off development that would enable maintaining SPEAR3
beam current constancy to less than 1% will most likely
require large-scale improvements to the electron gun and
possibly to the booster. These changes will not commence
until FY2007.
SPEAR3 Performance and Lattice Upgrades
– The accelerator physics and engineering groupscontinued to study and tune the SPEAR3 accelerator
to maximize its performance and stability. This work
includes investigating the sources of beam instability
(power supplies, rf systemcomponent vibration and
temperature-related motion, etc) and ongoing efforts to
characterize beam dynamical behavior as a function of
lattice and insertion device parameters. With regards to
the latter, a detailed study of the deleterious effects
of the new BL13 EPU on beam properties, and possible
cures, is in progress in collaboration with physicists
at other light sources. The results of this study will
be incorporated into the design of the BL13 EPU system.
An investigatory study of the possibility of circulating
short bunch electron bunches (<~1 ps) in the SPEAR3
storage ring was initiated. A new isochronous lattice
configuration was developed that would preserve the
short bunch length, and provide the option of
circulating the bunches for some small number of
revolutions (<1000), as opposed to storing the beam,
will be analyzed.
Gun Test Facility
– The GTF continued to support the LCLS injector group
through FY2006. Experiments performed included novel
in situ
methods to improve the cathode performance,
experiments to eliminate the correlated energy spread
produced by the gun, and beam-based screen resolution
measurements. New diagnostics will continue to be
developed including the electro-optic bunch length
measurement as well as testing new diagnostics such as
digital cameras and bunch charge monitors. The laser
will continue to be used to test transverse pulse
shaping techniques, the LCLS streak camera and methods
to improve the laser pointing stability.
Additional ultrafast electron diffraction experiments
were also planned. Improved detectors were tested and
the pulse length reduced to improve the temporal
resolution. The useful operating range of the gun for
electron diffraction has also been explored.
Beam Line and Facilities Improvements
BL1, 2, 3, 8 (bend beam lines)
–
Upgrade activities on bend magnet beam lines 1, 2, and 8
were limited to those essential to keep the beam lines
operating with higher SPEAR3 current. In particular,
during the 2006 shutdown, the BL2 beam position monitor
was upgraded for improved stability and the BL8 beam
position monitor shielding was upgraded for 500 mA
operations. BL3 will remain closed.
BL4
–
The BL4 upgrade continued with the fabrication of
components and is scheduled for installation during
FY2007. The BL4 upgrade is partially funded by DOE BER.
BL5 –
The BL5-1 M3
refocusing mirror system has been installed and
commissioned as has the shielding for 500 mA operation.
No other significant upgrades are scheduled.
BL7 –
The 500-mA upgrade installation was completed with the
temporary BL7-2 LN monochromator and the beam line was
commissioned. Assembly of the BL7-2 sagittal focusing
monochromator will be completed and the monochromator
will be installed and commissioned at the beginning of
the FY2007 run. BL7 and BL 7-3 upgrades are largely
funded by NIH NCRR.
BL10
– While no significant upgrades are planned, some
cooling enhancements of zero order beam masks downstream
of the BL10-1 monochromator have been scheduled.
New beam lines under development:
BL12
–
The in-vacuum ID was delivered and installed in the ring
as were the remaining dipole magnets and associated
vacuum chamber required to produce the SPEAR3 orbit
chicane. The hutches are being erected. The remaining
optical components will installed during October 2006.
It is anticipated that the beam line will start
commissioning by November 2006. The computing
infrastructure required to support this beam line is
being installed. A large-area CCD detector was procured
with an October 2006 delivery date. This beam line is
funded by the California Institute of Technology through
a gift from the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation.
BL13
–
The ID fabrication will continue. The beam line front
end design will be completed and fabrication will
commence. The M0
mirror system will be designed and the optic ordered. Design of the in-alcove beam transport system will start.
Rather than order a new monochromator for BL13, it has
been decided to relocate the BL5-1/5-2 spherical grating
monochromator, associated slits, and refocusing optics
to BL13. This relocation is planned for the summer 2007
shutdown. During the remainder of FY2006, the BL5-1/5-2
gratings and grating cooling system will be analyzed for
applicability to BL13. If new gratings are required, the
gratings will be ordered in FY2006.
SSRL Instrumentation and Control Software
XAS Instrument Control System Software and Computing
Developments
– The
new ICS software has been installed on BL7-3. This
system will run on the Microsoft Windows operation system and will form the basis for the upgrade of other
beam lines as the new standard SSRL beam line control
system. The system will be based on VXI instrumentation,
controlled using a National Instruments USB2 interface.
It is anticipated that the new ICS software running on
the Microsoft Windows XP operating system controlling
CAMAC hardware using the existing Grand Interconnect
hardware will be installed on a least one experimental
station.
Development of the SSRL dedicated beam line network will
continue. The initial design, consisting of several
VLANs has been implemented initially on BL7. Experience
gained during the operation of the new beam will fine
tune the design which will be extended to all beam lines
in the coming years.
Legacy OpenVMS based programs will still be available,
but will be run from a server style computer, displaying
on the workstation at the beam line. Projects will be
initiated to either port or replace such applications to
an operating system independent model.
Computers and Networking
– The SSRL network has been extended to Building 130.
Deployment of SAN storage technology is ongoing. Further
planning for the fiber-optic network backbone upgrade to
10 Gbit/s data rate will be performed and the
availability and cost will be analyzed. The beam line
network cabling and infrastructure system will be
reorganized to meet cable plant improvement
requirements. Some central windows servers will be
upgraded and a Windows 2003 Server will be deployed.
Central services will be available on Itanium-based
servers. In collaboration with the SLAC networking
group, a possible upgrade of the wireless network
infrastructure will be planned. New web-based SSRL user
administration applications will be developed and
deployed to the public.
Facilities and Infrastructure
–
Following the recommendations of the final safety review
for the LN distribution system, an oxygen deficiency
monitor network is being added and integrated into the
Building 120 fire alarm upgrade project. Implementation
of insulated piping to the LN-cooled monochromators will
then begin. The funding for the SLAC SLI SORIP
infrastructure project has been received The air handler
supplying cool air for the SPEAR3 power supply building
(Building 118) does not have the cooling capacity
necessary to support SPEAR3’s planned growth. It will be
replaced with a higher capacity unit and additional
ductwork will be installed.
Facility Research and Development
Inelastic Scattering and Advanced Spectroscopy Facility
for SPEAR3 –
An Inelastic X-ray Scattering and Advanced Spectroscopy
Facility is being developed that will eventually be
located at a new SPEAR3 insertion device beam line.
Various techniques complementary to the current
spectroscopy programs at SSRL will be carried out at
this facility. They include X-ray Raman scattering
(XRS), resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (RIXS),
selective X-ray absorption (S-XAS) and X-ray emission
spectroscopy (XES). XRS will widen the range of
absorption spectroscopy on low Z samples, traditionally
performed in the soft X-ray range, to systems and sample
conditions where the penetration of a hard X-ray probe
is essential. XRS can thus provide unique new insight
for,
e.g.,
studies of carbonaceous systems related to fossil fuels
and hydrogen storage under
in situ
conditions, water and aqueous systems in ambient and
extreme conditions, high pressure phases of gases and
the formation of methane hydrates. RIXS spectroscopy is
a novel technique to study in detail the local
electronic structure and spin states of,
e.g.,
3d transition metal compounds with hard X-rays. As
compared to conventional K-edge spectroscopy, it can
better isolate lowest unoccupied molecular orbital
(LUMO) resonances and has less lifetime broadening along
the energy transfer axis. Furthermore it provides
L-edge/M-edge like information. S-XAS, such as
site-selective EXAFS, combines the chemical sensitivity
of XES with EXAFS to provide more detailed structural
information in mixed valence systems. S-XAS can also be
used to extend the
k-range
of EXAFS beyond an absorption edge that otherwise would
limit the data collection, hence yielding more accurate
determination of neighbor distances. XES contains
chemical and structural information complementary to
XANES. All of these techniques are valuable in the study
of a wide range of systems including man-made and
biological catalysts as well as correlated systems.
Internal DOE-BES funding was allocated for
instrumentation development in FY2005. Additional
funding was obtained through non-DOE grant awards.
First, as part of the SSRL Structural Molecular Biology
program proposal to NIH-NCRR and DOE-BER (described in
the KP11 FTP) funding was awarded to: a) make the unit
compatible to perform emission scans as required for XES
and RIXS and b) purchase analyzer crystals for the
various proposed applications related to biological 3d
transition metal systems. Second, in collaboration with
Prof. Anders Nilsson (PI), an NSF proposal (NSF
CHE-0518637 1096374-2-QANAB) focusing on research on
water in ambient and extreme conditions was submitted
and funded. Funds were used to upgrade the XRS
spectrometer with parts for a second multicrystal
component which will double the efficiency to a total of
14 analyzers.
Three Si(553) analyzers were purchased for work on Cu Kβ
XES and the upgrade of thespectrometer for XES in
addition to XRS capabilities was undertaken. This
required the purchase and integration of two vertical
stages for simultaneous scanning of goniometer and
detector in order to obtain X-ray emission spectra. In
addition, a stand-alone alignment unit based on a
Newport table was built on which the complete XES setup
is placed. This unit can be attached tothe BL6-2 hutch
table, allowing for a fast turn around with other users
at BL6-2. SSRL thus has developed and implemented XES
(resonant and nonresonant) as well as XRS capabilities
at BL6-2.
In addition to the XRS work, XES on Mn and Cu Kβ lines
can currently be performed. The potential of the
technique was demonstrated with the observation of a
clear spectral shift for compounds with H2O
versus OH-
ligands. Commissioning work on the new XES spectrometer
was also performed at APS where, in addition,
experiments on Zn and Mn proteins were carried out.
Multiple beam-time proposals for SSRL-based XRS and XES
work were submitted in November. Finally, the process of
submitting a science-based proposal to the DOE for an
undulator-based facility was initiated. Several
potential users from groups are actively engaged in
contributing to the scientific case for this proposal.
Plans for development of dispersive optics for
pump-probe type XRS, XES and RIXS experiments will be
initiated as will implementation of
in situ
and high pressure instrumentation for XRS studies. The
development of the science-based funding proposal to DOE
for an undulator-based facility will be completed and
the proposal will be submitted by the end of FY2006.
Molecular Environmental and Interface Science
–
Molecular Environmental and Interface Science (MEIS)
research at SSRL focuses on the fundamental interfacial,
molecular- and nanoscale processes that control
contaminant and nutrient cycling in the biosphere with
the goals of elucidating local and global elemental
cycles and anthropogenic influences on the environment.
Knowledge of these processes is required to develop
contaminant remediation technologies and
environment-friendly industrial processes. Mass and
energy flow through surfaces and reactant
transformations, often driven by solar inputs, occurring
on nanoparticles, and mediated by bacteria, are major
research themes in this field, and offer discovery
opportunities for novel remediation technologies and
energy capture, conversion, and storage
materials/processes. Key areas of investigation at SSRL
include: (a) structural chemistry of water and dissolved
solutes, (b) structural chemistry and reactivity of
environmental nanomaterials (biominerals, oxide and
sulfide minerals, biofilms, and organic materials), (c)
reactions at environmental interfaces, including
sorption, precipitation and dissolution processes that
affect the bioavailability of heavy metals andother
contaminants, and (d) microbial transformations of
metals and anions. SSRL-based MEIS research utilizes
synchrotron-based X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS),
wide-angle X-ray scattering (WAXS), small-angle X-ray
scattering (SAXS), X-ray standing wave (XSW)
spectroscopy, and photoemission spectroscopy (PES).
These techniques provide unique capabilities to probe
structure/composition/function relationships in complex
environmental systems.
The Brown Group has continued studies at SSRL in the
following areas (1) abiotic and biotic
oxidation pathways of pyrite (FeS2)
and cinnabar (HgS) surfaces; (2) formation of ternary
surface complexes of dicarboxylic acids and metal ions
on metal oxide surfaces; (3) studies of the reactivity
of nanoparticles of hematite and cinnabar to heavy metal
contaminant ions; (3) interactions of metal ions with
biofilm- and organic polymer-coated metal oxide surfaces
under
in
situ
conditions; (4) XAFS spectroscopy studies of heavy metal
contaminated soils and mine wastes, including mercury
speciation in mine wastes from the California Coast
Range, zinc and arsenic speciation in soils from the
Carnoules region of southern France, and uranium
speciation in soils and sediments from Chihuahua,
Mexico; and (5) XAFS, micro-XAFS, and micro-XRD studies
of uranium in the Hanford Vadose Zone.
In the area of environmental nanomaterials (Bargar),
research focused on synthesizing and characterizing
bacteriogenic Mn oxides having different sizes and
properties. To support a SSRL-based post doc for this
research, a 5-year interdisciplinary proposal was
submitted to the NSFCRC program (Chemistry Division), in
collaboration with three other institutions (UC
Berkeley, Princeton, and Oregon Health and Sciences
University). Research will be initiated to study
structure/reactivity relationships of bacteriogenic
nanoparticulate UO2
(post doc supported byDOE-BER EMSP) as part of a
collaborative multi-disciplinary investigation of the
fundamental chemical factors controlling the long-term
release of uranium at remediated field sites. A two-day
user training workshop entitled, “Synchrotron X-ray
Scattering Techniques in Materials and Environmental
Sciences: Theory and Application” was held in May 2006.
The instrument development goals achieved in FY2006 were
to integrate the X-Y-Z scanning stage and detectors for
rapid XRF imaging measurements. User commissioning for
the μ-XAS and μ-XRF systems will be initiated in
winter/spring 2006 and completed during June/July 2006.
The procurement for an area X-ray detector for μ-XRD
measurements has been initiated.
Strongly Correlated Materials
–
The program of angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy
(ARPES) study of strongly correlated electronic
materials continues to be very active and productive in
its two main tasks: scientific research and advanced
instrumentation development and operation in support of
the research. The goal is get critical information about
the strongly correlated materials that cannot be
obtained by any other means.
During this period, the instrumentation development
takes two forms: i) Develop and design a new beam line
that will bring the ARPES capability to a new level. A
scientific case has been made for a new beam line. ii)
Upgrade current experimental end-station to have better
sample temperature control, and photoelectron detection
efficiency. Instrumentation development has been very
important to the success of the program, and significant
progress has been made on both fronts during the period.
We will have a new experimental chamber, an improved low
temperature sample manipulator, and an improved
spectrometer/detector. These improvements will also
lower the cost of the proposed future upgrades of the
beam line. These instrumentation innovation efforts have
benefited not only the research program described below,
but also other user programs at SSRL and ALS.
Research wise, the primarily focus is the many-body
interactions that are important to the mechanism for
high-temperature superconductivity; however, we have
also extended the work to other correlated oxides.
Work has been performed to systematically investigate
the evolution of Fermi surface and
quasiparticle dynamics through a topological transition
in correlated oxide Sr2-xLaxRuO4.
In collaboration with a group at University of St.
Andrews, we have performed a joint study which combines
de Haas-van Alphen (dHvA) and ARPES to track the carrier
doping evolution of the correlated electron system as
the material is doped through a critical point in the
band structure. We investigated the relationship of
proximity to this critical point and an evolution from
Fermi liquid to non Fermi liquid behavior. The
significantly improved momentum resolution enables this
investigation.
We uncovered evidence for small lattice polaron
formation by looking at the Frank-Condon type
of broadening in Ca2CuO2Cl2
and Sr2CuO2Cl2.
Small lattice polaron formation and its interplay with
magnetic interactions in undoped and underdoped
materials have been theoretically suggested for a
long time, direct spectroscopic evidence for this
behavior does not exist yet. By performing a temperature
dependent investigation, we expect to make progress on
this subject.
Important progress was made to understand the electronic
structure of a novel multilayer cuprate
material where the CuO2
layers are self-doped. These materials exhibit a number
of surprises as they are very high temperature
superconductors although simple valence counting would
have put them in the insulating regime. We have
uncovered a novel form of self-doping and a number of
surprises associated with it.
Important progress was made in understanding the role of
B1g
phonon coupling and superconducting transition
temperatures in multilayer materials such as Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8
and Bi2Sr2Ca2Cu3O10.
We found that this mode coupling is much stronger in
materials with multilayers of CuO2
planes in their unit cells and with higher Tc,
while this coupling is much weaker in cuprates with
single CuO2
layer and lower Tc.
Important progress was made in uncovering a phantom
Fermi surface and its nesting instability in
Ca3Ru2O7.
The delicate interplay between various degrees of
freedom and their intricate roles in
the rich physical phenomena is at the heart of physics
in complex oxides. In Ca3Ru2O7
, high resolution ARPES data reveal well defined
quasiparticle bands of unusually low weight, emerging in
line with the metallic phase of the material below ~30K.
At the structural phase transition temperature of 48K,
we find clear evidence for an electronic instability,
gapping large parts of the underlying Fermi surface that
appears to be nested. Metallic pockets are found to
survive in the small, non-nested sections, constituting
a low-temperature Fermi surface with two orders of
magnitude smaller volume than in all other metallic
ruthenates.
Important progress was made in understanding Fermi
surface and quasiparticle excitations of
Sr2RhO4.
We find well-defined quasiparticle excitations with a
highly anisotropic dispersion, suggesting a
quasi-two-dimensional Fermi liquid like ground state. A
quantitative analysis of the ARPES derived band
structure is in excellent agreement with dHvA and
specific heat data. This
work presents one of the rare quantitative comparison
(the other being Sr2RhO4)
between ARPES, transport and thermodynamic data down to
few percent level.
We have observed doping dependent coupling of electrons
to bosonic modes in the single-layer
Bi-cuprate Bi2Sr2CuO6.
We compare for the first time the self-energies in an
optimally doped and
strongly overdoped, non-superconducting single-layer
Bi-cuprate, Bi2Sr2CuO6.
Besides a strong overall weakening we also find that
weight of the self-energy in the overdoped system shifts
to higher energies. We have presented evidence that this
might well be related to the coupling of c-axis phonons
which are un-screened at optimal doping, being
particularly sensitive to the rapid change of the c-axis
screening in the doping range.
Chemical Physics of Surfaces and Liquids
–
The main focus of this research program is to use X-ray
and electron spectroscopies to address important
questions regarding chemical bonding on surfaces and in
aqueous solutions. Photoelectron spectroscopy (PES),
X-ray emission spectroscopy (XES), X-ray absorption
spectroscopy (XAS) and X-ray Raman spectroscopy (XRS)
provide an atom specific projection of the electronic
structure. Problems related to systems in catalysis,
energy technologies, electrochemistry and molecular
environmental science are studied using XES, XAS, XRS
and density functional theory (DFT) calculations.
Probing hydrogen bonding and the structure of liquid
water in aqueous systems are new and novel applications
of X-ray spectroscopic techniques. Instrument
development is an important part of the activity to
provide new spectrometers, and enable measurements at
high gas pressures and at liquid interfaces.
Detailed studies of water adsorbed on TiO2
and Fe2O3
at ambient pressures using the differential pumped XPS
systems continued, as have hydrogenation studies of
carbon nanotubes for investigations of the potential of
carbon based materials as hydrogen storage materials.
Studies ofwater at high pressures and temperatures,
different pH and in various aqueous solutions have
provided new information to address structure, hydrogen
bonding and electronic structure of water in the bulk
and in the influence of ions.
Molecular Adsorbates on Surfaces. XPS and XAS studies were performed on water adsorbed on
Cu surfaces at ambient conditions. At pressures of 1
Torr, water dissociates to form a co-adsorbed
oxygen-OH-water overlayer on Cu(110). The relative
concentration of the different species depends strongly
on temperature and relative humidity. On Cu(111) the
interaction of water with the surface at 1 Torr and room
temperature is extremely weak, resulting in a bare
surface with no adsorbed water. These results show that
in order for water to wet a Cu surface, it is necessary
to form OH groups on the surface allowing for strong
hydrogen bonding between water and OH.
Catalysis.
Using a combination of density functional theory
calculations and XES and XAS for nitrogen on Cu and Ni
surfaces, a detailed picture has been obtained of the
chemisorption bond. It is suggested that the adsorption
bond strength and hence the activity of transition metal
surfaces ascatalysts for chemical reactions can be
related to certain characteristics of the surface
electronic structure, in particular the center of the d
band is important.
Water in Aqueous Systems.
New models of the structure of liquid water based on XAS
and XRS experiments which go against the existing
understanding based on theoretical simulations were
proposed. New experiments with XRS have demonstrated
important isotope effects between H2O
and D2O
which indicate that the discovered asymmetry in hydrogen
bonding in water could be related to quantum effects in
the motion of the hydrogen atoms. New experiments of
water using photoelectron spectroscopy have been
performed using both valence and core levels providing
insights into the electronic structure rearrangements
due to hydrogen bonding.
Instrument Development.
A new UHV surface science end-station was completed and
installed at BL5. A highly efficient soft X-ray
spectrometer optimized for C, N and O K-edges has been
designed and is under construction and a
differentially-pumped high-pressure cell using cryogenic
technology that can be inserted into this UHV system is
being assembled.
Development of Resonant Coherent X-ray Scattering
–
The scientific motivation for the development program
outlined below is the investigation of the critical
fluctuations of a magneticdomain structure at the
magnetic-paramagnetic phase transition. This research
falls into the general area of critical fluctuations at
phase transitions for which theory predicts that the
order parameter diverges at the transition temperature.
For magnetic phase transitions this implies that the
domain size should diverge,
i.e.,
right at the transition temperature a single magnetic
domain should extend –momentarily– over the entire
sample. However, this has never been observed
experimentally. One of the major reasons for this lack
of experimental proof is that impurities and defects
limit/influence these fluctuations. This limitation can
be overcome by studying critical fluctuations in
ultra-thin films with quasi 2-dimensional magnetization.
Such ferromagnetic films can be prepared essentially
defect free by epitaxial growth with thicknesses of only
a few monolayers. A further advantage of studying a thin
film is that the fluctuations are expected to be much
slower in thin films than in bulk materials. To
investigate the nature of these critical fluctuations,
the following four experiments will be undertaken:
-
Resonant Small Angle Scattering of Incoherent Soft
X-rays
Resonant scattering at the dichroic L3
absorption edge of magnetic transition metals will
yield statistical information about the magnetic
domain structure such as average domain size and
domain shape. Hence, when investigating the
temperature dependence of this statistical
information close to the transition temperature, the
average domain size of the critical magnetic
fluctuations can be derived.
-
X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy (alias Dynamic
‘Light’ Scattering)
By
scattering of coherent photons, information about
the dynamics of the fluctuations can be derived from
the time dependence of the scattering intensities. A
third generation synchrotron light source like
SPEAR3 will enable time resolving dynamics occurring
on the microsecond time regime.
-
Ultra-Fast, High-Resolution, Lensless Imaging of
Magnetic Domain Structures
One potential application of SLAC’s upcoming X-ray
free electron laser LCLS will be ultrafast,
high-resolution lensless imaging. This will allow
recording of femtosecond snap shots of the magnetic
domain structure at and in the vicinity of the
magnetic phase transition. A series of such images
will enable distinguishing “real” magnetic
fluctuations from defect-pinned fluctuations.
-
Ultra-fast X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy
At LCLS, a beam splitter and a delay line will be
used to obtain two femtosecond short X-ray pulses
separated by a variable delay ranging from a femto-
to a few picoseconds. Using both these pulses for
lensless imaging of the magnetic domain structure
will reveal the dynamics of the magnetization
fluctuations on a femto- to picosecond time scale.
Commissioning of the rebuilt BL5-2 continued, which also
included commissioning of the dedicated end station for
coherent soft X-ray scattering. Double pinhole test
scattering patterns were recorded to characterize the
coherence properties of the beam line. In addition, a
novel implementation for coherence measurements based on
a non-redundant array of pinhole structures was
developed and successfully applied.
The feasibility of phase contrast imaging in resonant
soft X-ray holography was demonstrated by imaging of a
magnetic domain structure. The important implication of
this achievement is that sample damage can be reduced
significantly by using phase instead of amplitude
scattering contrast.
In addition, multiple reference beam Fourier transform
holography has been developed. Since an image is
obtained simultaneously from each reference beam, the
effectiveness of the imaging technique increases
linearly with the number of reference holes. This allows
to further reduce the required dose for imaging on the
nano-scale, which is in particular important for
radiation sensitive samples like organic materials.
The thin film preparation chamber assembled during
FY2005 has been commissioned. First ultrathin magnetic
films for the investigation of critical magnetic
fluctuations have been grown. In preparation for these
experiments, temperature control, earth field
compensation, and an optical MOKE system to characterize
the magnetic properties of the thin films were
developed.
Small and Wide Angle Scattering Studies of Soft Matter &
Colloids
–
A proposal for a new SAXS/WAXS Materials Science beam
line at SSRL has been developed in response to the
burgeoning demand for the technique in a host of modern
nano-scale science applications. The beam line’s design
takes advantage of the accrued knowledge of the decades
of experimental scattering from synchrotron sources in
the field of materials science. Detailed plans
concerning its physical specifications and configuration
are already in place: with a double crystal
monochromator (interchangeable between silicon [111]
crystals and multilayers) and a horizontal and vertical
focusing toroidal mirror and five meter path length
downstream of the sample environment. This will provide
a beam ~1013
photons able to probe correlation lengths within
physical media up to half a micron in size at time
resolutions of 100 ms or less, thereby opening up a
facility for a whole new range of science. Some of this
new science that would be made accessible by this
geometry would include many pore size distributions
(spatially) and matrix complexations (temporally) that
are currently beyond the abilities of modern facilities.
Nanoparticles for Environmental Sorption Control.
This project focused on the nano-scalestructural
chemistry and environmental chemical dynamics of
bacteriogenic manganese oxide (MnO) nanoparticles.
Investigations at BL1-4 addressed the relationships
between particle size and MnO structure and stability
and the factors controlling the colloid chemistry of MnO
nanoparticles in aquatic systems. Insofar as Mn plays
unique and important roles in local and global elemental
cycles, including those of C, S, N, Fe and numerous
other trace metals, the knowledge gained from this
project will contribute towards our understanding of the
dynamics that control the chemistry of our soils,
natural waters, and atmosphere. Initial measurements of
bacteriogenic Mn oxide particle sizes in
bacteria/mineral mixtures were made allowing the
feasibility and test techniques for dispersing particles
to be assessed.
Reflection Geometry SAXS.
The capabilities of the new experimental hutch permitted
collection ofthe first SAXS data in a reflection
geometry, studying controlled growth of silicon
nanotubes intended for nano-scale thermoelectric
applications. In an effort to access the pores and
achieve significant alignment, a method was developed
for producing vertical pores out of the plane of a
substrate. Cubic mesoporous titania was believed to have
produced an ultra-flat hexagonal pattern from its 111
face that could be used to surface nucleate vertical
growth in the silica 2D hexagonal system SBA-15 and
hence the creation of accessible, aligned pores. Early
data, in the reflection geometry, permitted
characterization of the packing arrangement and aspect
ratio of these nanotubes, which revealed difficulties in
the synthesis, leading to misaligned tubular structures,
which remain to be corrected.
Nanoporous Metallic Media. Nanoporous metals were fabricated electrochemically by
selective dissolution or ‘dealloying’. When immersed in
a suitably aggressive reagent (e.g.
nitric acid), themore active metal was removed leaving
behind a ‘sponge-like’ bicontinous network of the noble
element. We have studied AgAu and CuPt alloys, which
formed nanoporous Au or Pt, respectively. SAXS has been
used to characterize the pore sizes and the pore
morphology as a function of dealloying time (1 minute to
3 days). We found that with increasing dealloying time
the average ligament spacing increases and the
morphology develops into a bicontinous network which
then coarsens. In a related study, diffraction has been
used to characterize the strain that develops during
dealloying.
Structural Properties of Novel Materials
–
Several major subgroups of materials are explored in
this area, including the local structure of
non-crystalline materials, thin films, and nanoporous
materials.
Non-crystalline Materials
–
A second experimental run was performed on the structure
of liquid water. Several experimental improvements were
made, including using an energy of 19.6 keV instead of
12 keV, which increases the maximum momentum transfer to
19.7 Å-1.
Secondly, asmaller, 600 micron orifice was used in the
water jet. The smaller water diameter results in better
energy resolution within the diffracted beam analyzer,
which allows for better resolution between the elastic
and Compton components of the diffracted beam. We also
implemented a thermal bath for the recirculated water
beam enabling us to measure the scattering both at room
temperature (23 C) and at 5 C, very close to the density
maximum of 4 C.
The analysis of the scattering from water is underway.
Some of the challenges needing to be met during the
analysis include the correct separation of the elastic
and Compton components of the scattered beam. The
advantage of increased energy resolution improves but
does not eliminate the overlap between the elastic and
Compton components. In a small region of momentum
transfer(roughly between 2 and 6 Å-1)
there is overlap of the two peaks. Analytical techniques
are being developed to consistently separate the two
components. A second challenge is the correct form of
the independent scattering. A molecular form factor has
been calculated for water vapor, but it is expected that
there will be subtle changes in the shape of the form
factor for liquid water. Weintend to use the excess
electron density at small atomic separation to modify
the form factor for liquid water. We plan to submit the
work for publication during this period as well as write
the doctoral dissertation.
Thin Film Structure
–
Studies on organic semiconductors have been extended to sexithiophene and substituted oligothiophenes, such as
p-tolyl-trithiophene-p-tolyl,
and studies will be initiated of other semiconducting
conjugated polymers, such as
poly[5,5’-bis(3-dodecyl-2-thienyl)-2,2’bithiophene],
PQT-12, which has a high field-effect mobility.
Nanoporous Metals
–
Nanoporous metals can be fabricated electrochemically by
selective dissolution, or ‘dealloying’. When immersed in
a suitably aggressive reagent, the more active metal is
removed leaving behind a ‘sponge-like’ bicontinous
network of the noble element. Alloys of interest include
AgAu, CuAu, CuPt, which form nanoporous Au or Pt for
example. X-ray
scattering methods (SAXS and GIXS) have been used to
carefully characterize the pores and the near-surface
structure in these materials.
Charge Density Wave Materials
–
Rare earth (R) tellurides (RTe2
and
RTe3)
are ideal materials in which to study charge density
waves (CDW), since the CDW gap is large and large
crystals can be grown. High-resolution X-ray diffraction
has been used to study the nature of the incommensurate
and commensurate CDWs in
RTe2
and
RTe3
with initially
R=La
and Ce. From the diffraction data, the atomic
displacements, which permit a deeper understanding of
the observed thermodynamic and transport properties of
these materials, have been obtained.
Ultra-trace and Microanalysis
–
A micro-focus X-ray mirror system using Kirkpatrick-Baez
(KB) optics was commissioned in the back hutch of BL6-2
and first real data studying interplanetary dust
particles were collected. Initially, this required a
profound understanding of the alignment of the newly
upgraded upstream beam line optics illuminating the
virtual source of the KB system. This adjustable virtual
source slit allows mapping to be carried out at variable
focal spot sizes between approximately 2 and 15 microns.
Photon fluxes fall in the 108
– 1010
photon/second range depending on the X-ray spot size, and
the accessible energy range covers readily the elements
Mg through Br. An aluminum-coated BN window allows
simultaneous imaging of the sample with a high
resolution optical microscope during the X-ray
measurements. A helium gas shower is mounted above the
sample to minimize radiation damage (due to ozone
generation) as well as spectrum “contamination” by argon
fluorescence from air. This shower creates a gentle flow
of He without introducing vibrations to the sample mount.
The X-ray hutch itself has been temperature-stabilized
minimizing possible X-ray beam and/or sample drift
during measurement. In addition, the data collection
software SUPER was upgraded allowing the collection of
the entire emitted fluorescence spectrum for each pixel
rather than collecting only predefined single channel
analyzer windows for selected elements of interest. This
is crucial in particular for studying samples containing
a variety of elements such as interplanetary dust
particles. In those cases overlapping fluorescence lines
in particular from neighboring elements can easily lead
to false images of the elemental distribution. Efforts
were made to evaluate different software packages for
quantitative analysis of the individual fluorescence
spectra. A software package developed at the ESRF called
PyMca is currently being employed for quantitative
analysis. The KB-based experiments in FY2005 were very
successful, given the short amount of beam time
available for characterization of the optical setup. In
addition to optics characterization, elemental maps and
trace element spectra were obtained for several thin
sections of micrometeorites. These samples included
round-robin samples provided by the Bulk Chemistry
subteam leader of the Stardust Preliminary Examination
Team. Our microprobe has been used in the preliminary
examination of the samples returned by the Stardust NASA
mission which swept through the tail of a comet (comet
Wild 2) resulting in the first successful sample return
mission since the Apollo program.
In FY2006, the KB optic-based microfocus facility has
opened up for external user groups. A first user group
from Canada has already been on line in January 2006,
studying Fe distribution in fruit fly brains as a model
for human Alzheimer disease. In addition, SSRL
scientists performed preliminary test measurements for
upcoming user groups studying Cu distribution in mice
liver as a model for the Wilson disease, as well as of
transition metal distribution in arthropod tools, such
as spider fangs or worm teeth.
In addition to the work on the microprobe, a new TXRF
chamber was designed, built and commissioned on BL6-2
mostly for studying small samples from the Genesis
mission. Despite its hard landing, this mission returned
fragmented samples of solar wind collected at the
Lagrangian point for over two years. TXRF, due to the
ability to distinguish between surface contamination
(from Utah desert) and the true implanted solar wind, is
an especially effective technique for studying these
types of samples. In particular, the sample holder of
this new setup was tailored for mounting small (cm2)
size samples without adding any contamination. In close
collaboration with the PI of the Genesis mission,
flight-spare samples and flown Sapphire samples have
been analyzed with high detection sensitivity. These
indicate that while some of the returned sample pieces
have significant surface roughness and contamination,
effectively reducing the sensitivity of the measurement,
others are sufficiently clean and smooth to enable us to
measure bulk solar
wind of dominant species (e.g.
Fe). Further examination of samples will determine
whether minority species will be able to be quantified.
Finally, the proposal to NIH (1 R01 EB004321-01) with
the title “A multi-keV X-ray microscopy facility for
bio-imaging” for development of a zone plate-based,
multi-keV Transmission X-ray Microscope (TXM) facility
was funded in May 2005 by the Bioengineering Research
Partnerships program of NIBIB. The total award was
distributed over four years and started in May 2005. The
purchase order for the basic TXM instrument from Xradia
Inc. was placed in September 2005. This instrument will
provide important and currently at SSRL unavailable
capabilities for the study of biological systems
in-situ,
such as the imaging of elemental distributions within
single cells or tissues with high spatial resolution.
The full field microscope will operate using photon
energies between 5 – 13 keV and exploits the advantages
of hard X-rays for 2D and 3D absorption and phase
contrast microscopy such as large penetration depth, a
large depth of focus, analytical sensitivity and
compatibility with wet specimens. Together this will
allow high resolution
in-situ
imaging, tomography and spectromicroscopy without
extensive sample preparation. The TXM will be delivered
from Xradia Inc. in October of 2006. We are currently
building a new X-ray hutch on BL6-2 for this
high-resolution microscope. It is anticipated that
commissioning will begin in fall of 2006 and by the end
of 2006 resolution test structures will be imaged in 2D
and 3D with a spatial resolution below 60 nm in
absorption contrast.
XAS Studies as a Probe of Electronic Structure /
Contribution to Function
–
X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), at the ligand and
metal K- and metal L-edges, is used to determine the
electronic and geometric structure of metal-based
centers in inorganic and bioinorganic systems. The goal
is to understand the involvement of the metal center in
catalytic cycles important in industrial and biological
catalysis. The experimental approach is complemented by
Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations,
photoemission spectroscopy measurements, valence bond
simulations and the development of data analysis tools,
as well as by other non-synchrotron-based methodologies
including MCD, resonance Raman and EPR spectroscopies,
where applicable. The combined approach enables
significant insight into geometric and electronic
structure and their contributions to reactivity.
Currently, studies are focused on systems containing
copper, iron, titanium, manganese, molybdenum, and
tungsten, with the anticipation of extending these
studies to other transition metal sites.
Copper –The
geometric and electronic structures of two mononuclear
CuO2
complexes [Cu(O2){HB(3-Ad-5-iPrpz)3}]
(1)
and [Cu(O2)(β-diketiminate)]
(2)
have been evaluated using CuK- and L-edge XAS studies in
combination with valence bond configuration interaction
(VBCI) simulations and spin unrestricted broken symmetry
density functional theory (DFT) calculations. These
systems are related to oxygen activation at a single
copper center, as in dopamine βmonooxygenase and
peptidylglycine α-hdroxylating monoxygenase. Cu K- and
L-edge XAS data indicated the Cu(II) and Cu(III) nature
of
1
and
2,
respectively. Total integrated intensity under the
L-edges showed that the ψ*LUMO
in
1
and
2
consists of 20% and 28% Cu character, respectively,
which is indicative of a very covalent ground state in
both complexes, although more so in
1.
This is consistent with VBCI simulations, which also
indicated that the ground state in
2
has more d8
n-character. DFT calculations showed that the ψ*LUMO
in both complexes is dominated by O2
character, although the O2n-
character is higher in
1.
It was also shown that the strong donor ligand in
2
is responsible for tuning the molecule towards more Cu(III)-peroxide like character in contrast to
trispyrazolyl borate in
1
which leads to a Cu(II)-superoxide species.
Heme-Copper Oxidases –
The geometric and electronic structure of the untethered
heme-peroxocopper model complex [(F8TPP)FeIII-(O22-)-CuII(TMPA)](ClO4)
(1)
has been investigated usingCu and Fe K-edge EXAFS
spectroscopy and DFT calculations in order to describe
its geometricand electronic structure. The Fe and Cu
K-edge EXAFS data indicated a Cu···Fe distance of ~3.72
Å. Spin unrestricted DFT calculations for the ST
= 2 spin state were performed on [(P)FeIII-(O22-)-CuII(TMPA)]+
as a model of
1.
The peroxo unit is bound end-on to the copper, and
side-on to the high spin iron, for an overall µ-η1:η2
coordination mode. The FeIII-peroxide
η2-bond
has two
components that arise from the donor interactions of the
peroxide π*σ
and π *v orbitals with the Fe
dxz
and dxy
orbitals, which give rise to σ and δ bonds,
respectively, while for the Cu site the
primary bonding interaction is between the peroxide
π*σ
and Cu dz2
orbitals. The π*σ
interaction
of O22-with
both Cu (η1)
and Fe (η2)
provides an effective superexchange pathway for strong
antiferromagnetic coupling between the metal centers.
Non-Heme and Heme Iron
Cyanides
–
Distinct spectral features at the Fe L-edge of the two
compounds K3[Fe(CN)6]
and K4[Fe(CN)6]
have been identified and characterized as arising from
contributions of the ligand π* orbitals due to
metal-to-ligand back-bonding Analysis of the L-edge
spectral shape, total intensity and energy shift have
been used to quantify the contributions of σ-donation
and π-back-donation to metal cyanide bonding. The
methodology developed demonstrates the application of Fe
L-edge XAS as a direct probe of metal-to-ligand
back-bonding.
Heme vs. Non-Heme Fe
–
Fe porphyrin compounds, or hemes, form the basis for
electron transfer in a number of biological systems,
with the most well-known being the cytochromes, which
effect electron transfer by shuffling between low spin
Fe(II) and Fe(III). The delocalization of the Fe
d-orbitals into the porphyrin ring has been difficult to
study spectroscopically because of the dominant
porphyrin π →π* transitions, which obscure the metal
based d-d bands. Recently, we have developed a novel
methodology that allows for the interpretation of the
multiplet structure of Fe L-edges in terms of
differential orbital covalency (i.e. differences in
delocalization of the different d orbitals) using a
valence bond configuration interaction (VBCI) model.
Applied to heme systems, this methodology allows
experimental study of the delocalization of the Fe
d-orbitals into the porphyrin ring. This methodology has
been applied to study two model systems
[Fe(tpp)(ImH)2]Cl
and [Fe(tpp)(ImH)2]
(low spin Fe(III) and Fe(II), respectively) and have
compared their multiplet structure to those of the two
low spin non-heme compounds
[Fe(tacn)2]Cl2
and [Fe(tacn)2]Cl3.
The Fe L-edge spectra are very sensitive to the effects
of π donation and π back-donation. The e1
hole (in heme,
D4h;
t2g,
in
Oh)
in the ground-state electronconfiguration of low spin
Fe(III), creates a dominant spectroscopic feature which
was quantified in
terms of
π
donation. The L-edge spectrum of [Fe(tpp)(ImH)2]
exhibits additional transitions caused by back-bonding,
which was also quantified. It was found that heme acts
as a substantial �-donor to Fe(III) but only a minimal
�-acceptor to Fe(II), indicating the electron transfer
involves a hole-based super-exchange mechanism.
Siderophores
–
In order to overcome the immense difference between
environmentally and nutritionally available Fe, many
microorganisms produce low-molecular weight
iron-chelators called siderophores. Our recently
developed L-edge methodology, described above, provides
a way of studying the bonding in these compounds. Fe
L-edge data on a small set of compounds,
K3[Fe(oxalate)3],
[Fe(pha)3]
and K3[Fe(catecholate)3]
have been obtained. Results show that both
the Fe K- and the L-edges shift to lower energy across
the series: K3[Fe(ox)3]<
[Fe(pha)3]<K3[Fe(cat)3].
This shift indicates a decrease in effective nuclear
charge and an increase in electron donation by the ligands. The total intensity of the Fe L-edge
transitions decreases across the series,
implying that the Fe-O bonds of K3[Fe(cat)3]
are the most covalent of the compounds. By simulating
the shape of the spectra, it has been possible to
calculate the σ and π contributions to bonding in the
compounds, providing insight into the factors which
affect the differences in their thermodynamic stability.
Iron-Sulfur
–
Ligand K-edge XAS has been used to obtain a quantitative
description of Fe-S bonding in Fe-S model complexes and
protein active sites. The results of these studies have
been correlated to the extent of H-bonding and
differences in redox potentials. To develop a
quantitative description of hydrogen bonding in Fe-S
systems, a series of P450 model complexes, where the
amount of hydrogen bonding was systematically varied,
were examined by S K-edge XAS. The data show a dramatic
decrease in pre-edge intensity with increasing H-bonding
to the ligated thiolate. DFT calculations reproduced
these effects and showed that the observed changes are in
fact solely due to H-bonding to the thiolate ligand. The
energy of the H-bonding interaction was estimated to be
-2.5 kcal/mol in the gas phase. The rather small
H-bonding energy appears to contrast the large change in
ligand-metal bond covalency (30%) observed in the data.
A bond
decomposition analysis of the total energy was developed
to correlate the pre-edge intensity change to the change
in Fe-S bonding interaction on H-bonding. This analysis
showed that the Fe-S interaction energy is greatly
reduced due to H-bonding. This effect is greater for the
reduced than the oxidized state, leading to an ~350 mV
increase in the redox potential. It was found from a VBCI
model that Eo
should vary linearly with the covalency of the Fe-S bond
in the oxidized state, which can be determined directly
from S K-edge XAS. The above study was extended to a
hydrogen bonded [Fe4S4]2+
cube, which had an elongated core structure in contrast
to the compressed
core structures of most [Fe4S4]2+
cubes. A decrease in pre-edge intensity was observed for
the H-bonded cube. DFT calculations indicated that the
change in Fe-S covalency observed experimentally had
almost equal contributions from the cluster elongation
and the H-bonding
interaction. These calculations also indicated that the
elongation of the [Fe4S4]2+
cube changes the spin topology of the ground
state due to redistribution of the ligand superexchange
interactions in the cluster.
The geometric and electronic structure of the active
site of the nonheme iron enzyme nitrile hydratase
(NHase) has been studied using S K-edge XAS and DFT
calculations. Using thiolate (RS-),
sulfenate (RSO-)
and sulfinate (RSO2-)
ligated model complexes to provide benchmark spectral
parameters, the results showed that the S K-edge XAS is
sensitive to the oxidation state of S-containing ligands
and that the spectrum of the RSO-species
changes upon protonation as the SO bond is elongated (by
~0.1 Å). These signature features were used to identify
the three cysteine residues coordinated to the low-spin
FeIII
in the active site of NHase as CysS-,
CysSOH andCysSO2- in
both the NO-bound inactive form and the in the
photolyzed active form. These results were correlated to
geometry optimized DFT calculations. The pre-edge region
of the XAS
spectrum is sensitive to the Zeff
of the Fe and revealed that the Fe in the [FeNO]6
NHase specieshas an effective nuclear charge very close
to that of its photolyzed FeIII
counterpart. DFT calculations revealed that this results
from the strong π back-bonding in to the π anti-bondingorbital
of NO, which shifts charge from the formally t26
low-spin ferrous center.
Titanium Cyclopentadienyl Catalysts
– Ti-TEMPO complexes (TEMPO =
2,2,6,6tetramethylypiperidine-N-oxyl) provide a means
for generating Ti(III) complexes by homolysis of the
Ti-O bond. The rate of Ti-O bond homolysis depends on
the ancillary ligation to the titanium, and it has been
determined that bis-Cp-Ti-TEMPO (Cp=cyclopentadienyl)
complexes readily undergo homolytic cleavage, while the
mono-Cp-Ti-TEMPO complexes do not. Recently, Ti K- and
Cl K-edge XAS studies have been applied to a series of
Ti-TEMPO complexes
(TiCl3TEMPO,
TiCl2CpTEMPO,
TiClCp2TEMPO).
The XAS results indicate that these complexes are best
described as Ti(IV)-TEMPO anions. The Cl K-edges show
that the replacement of Cl by Cp weakens the remaining
ligands, demonstrating a spectator ligand effect which
is one factor that contributes to Ti-TEMPO bond
homolysis. However, correlation of the XAS results to
DFT calculations shows that stabilization of the
three-coordinate product by Cp makes a more significant
contribution to the energetics of Ti-O(TEMPO) bond
homolysis.
PES Studies of Electronic Structure Contribution to
Function
– The shake-up satellite structure present in core and
valence photoemission spectroscopy (PES) data is being
used in combination with a valence bond configuration
interaction (VBCI) model to experimentally quantify
electronic relaxation (i.e. the change in electronic
structure of metal complexes upon oxidation) and its
contributions to reduction potentials and kinetics of
electron transfer. Variable-energy PES (VEPES)
experiments provide the tool to maximize the metal
contribution, while minimizing that of the ligand, to
the valence band region through cross section effects
(delayed
maximum and Cooper minimum) and resonance enhancement.
VEPES data on a series of model iron complexes – high
spin [FeCl6]4-/3-
and low spin [Fe(CN)6]4-/3-,
[Fe(tacn)2]2+/3+,
[FeTpp(HIm)2]1+/0,
[FeTpp(Py)2]1+/0
– were measured and analysis initiated.
Materials Research
Research carried out by SSRL faculty and staff and
associated Stanford faculty and students covers a broad
set of disciplines: (1) Complex Materials; (2) Magnetic
Materials; (3) Scientific and Educational Gateway
Program (through FY2006); (4) Novel Materials and Model
Systems for the
Study of Correlated Phenomena; (5) Nano-scaled Magnetism
in the Vortex State of High-Tc
Cuprates; (6) Nano-scale Electronic Self-Organization in
Complex Oxides; (7) Nano-Magnetism;
(8) Behavior of Charges, Excitons and Plasmons at
Organic/Inorganic Interfaces; and (9) Development and
Mechanistic Characterization of Alloy Fuel Cell
Catalysts. Areas (4) through (8) are collaborative
efforts of the SSRL X-ray Laboratory for Advanced
Materials and the Stanford University Geballe Laboratory
for Advanced Materials.
1. Complex Materials
Z.-X. Shen, S. Doniach, M. Greven, R.B. Laughlin, X.J.
Zhou, K. Tanaka, H. Li, L. Lu, K.Downum, Y. Cho, J.
Hancock, D. Santiago, D. Schroeter, L. Zhou, X. Zhou,
B.A. Bernevig
The team has conducted comprehensive experiments using
photoemission (Shen), scattering (Greven and Shen), and
theoretical investigation (Laughlin and Doniach) on
complex materials, and has made substantial progress in
this period. There also are synergetic interactions with
the nano-science programs of Greven, especially in the
area of single crystal growth, and Shen’s core program
on strongly correlated materials.
A major focus of the program is the electron-doped
materials that have presented an important challenge to
the systematic understanding of high-temperature
superconductors. The Greven group
has continued its successful effort on the
electron-doped superconductor Nd2-xCexCuO4
(NCCO), built on its early success in growing
high-quality single crystals. Recent results include the
first determination of spin-correlations in
superconducting samples, which constitutes significant
progress toward a full understanding of the normal state
of the electron-doped superconductors.
Since superconductivity in high-Tc
cuprates appears in close proximity to the
antiferromagnetic phase, it is essential to understand
the nature of nearby magnetic ground states. Through
careful X-ray and neutron diffraction work, Greven
discovered that the oxygen reduction process, required
to render NCCO superconducting, transforms a fraction of
the crystals into cubic
(Nd,Ce)2O3,
and that the field-effects observed by others and
ascribed to a quantum phase transition of NCCO are not
intrinsic, but due to this secondary phase.
Consequently, the question of genuine magnetic field
effects in NCCO has remained a very interesting,
unresolved research topic. By studying the magnetic
field effect on the spin excitations, Greven was
recently able to obtain new data consistent with the
absence of field-induced magnetic order [Motoyama
et al.,
preprint]. Moreover, these measurements constitute the
first neutron scattering study of the effects of a
magnetic field on the superconducting magnetic gap in
NCCO. The discovery of spurious magnetism in NCCO is a
good example of the benefits of a synergistic growth and
scattering effort like that by Greven.
Greven continued the novel use of inelastic X-ray
scattering to investigate the collective charge
excitations in the model high-temperature superconductor
Hg1201, the single-layer material with the highest value
of Tc,
and of the parent compound La2CuO4.
This latter work, carried out at the APS and made
possible by newly available large Hg1201 crystals grown
by Greven, led to the discovery of a remarkably rich
structure of electron-hole pair excitations in the
cuprate superconductors.
Greven's work on the structural phase diagram and
charge-order phenomena in the layered manganite was
extended to cover a wider range of doping as well as
neutron scattering. These results will allow a
comprehensive understanding of the structural and
magnetic phase diagram.
The angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES)
component of the program (Shen) has two primary tasks,
research, and operation of the beam line 10.0.1
end-station at the ALS in support of this research. That
activity also benefited a broader community performing
ARPES experiments using the end-station.
The focus during this period of time is to understand
the nature of collective modes coupled to cuprate
superconductors. Data with very high signal-to-noise
level, together with a numerical method developed in
collaboration with Ward Plummer’s group (Oak Ridge
National Laboratory), enabled a glimpse of the phonons
and their coupling to electrons in cuprates. This
represents the first experimental evidence for
multi-boson coupling in cuprates.
Another area of major progress during the period is the
new insight on the polaronic behavior of single hole in
undoped cuprate. Based on ARPES data from La2CuO4
and phonon spectra fromneutron scattering, theoretical
calculation by Gunnarsson’s group (Max Plank Institute)
show that the spectra are consistent with the material
being in the polaronic regime, which is consistent with
our earlier finding for copper oxide chloride.
Shen’s group also has made important technical progress
in applying synchrotron radiation for high resolution
spectroscopy experiments. The resolution and flux
density at the ALS have been a critical factor for the
program in generating a significant database. On the
other hand, this also raises the technical problem of
space charging. Shen’s group has systematically
characterized this problem and our finding is generally
useful in guiding high resolution photoemission
experiments in third generation synchrotron radiation
facilities.
A major advance by Shen’s group during this period is
the discovery of nodal quasiparticle and nodal antinodal
anisotropy in layered colossal magnetoresistive
manganites. This finding providesdeep new insights on
the “pseudogap” phenomena in cuprates. The pseudogap
behavior has for a long time been considered to exist
only in superconducting materials, and thus is directly
related to high-temperature superconductivity. Finding
this same behavior in ferromagnetic state suggests that
the relationship between “pseudogap” and
superconductivity is more subtle. In particular, this
finding supports the notion that there are two
“pseudogaps”, and the larger pseudogap is in fact a
reflection of a competing state to superconductivity.
Thus, both superconducting and pseudogap phases are
manifestation of the same underlying physics that give
rise to the rich and intricate phenomena seen in these
complex oxides.
The work of the Laughlin group in 2005 was conducted
mainly by David I. Santiago and Zaira I. Nazario. The
Laughlin group has studied the phase diagram in cuprates
high Tc
superconductors.Recent experimental measurements suggest
the coexistence of various phases of matter in different
regions of the pseudogap regime. Guided by such
experiments the group has studied the properties of a
spin-density-wave antiferromagnetic mean-field ground
state with d-wave superconducting (DSC) correlations.
This work concentrates in the case when
antiferromagnetic order is turned on weakly on top of
the superconductivity, which corresponds to the onset of
antiferromagnetism at a critical doping. In such a case
a small gap proportional to the weak antiferromagnetic
gap opens up for nodal quasiparticles, and the
quasiparticle peak would be discernible.
The program looked broadly at the many-body problem in
condensed matter system, beyond the
high-Tc
superconductors and transition metal oxides. Work on the
superfluid to Mott insulator transition in bosonic
systems has been done, where the phase diagram of a
single component Bose Einstein Condensate (BEC) in an
optical lattice at zero temperature was obtained. In
that work, the discontinuous nature of the transition
between the superfluid and the Mott insulator (under
certain conditions) was elucidated, as well as its
independence on commensuration of the number of bosons
with the lattice. Recently, measurements which could be
interpreted as such a transition have been performed by
Mark Kasevich's group of Stanford University. While,
being superfluids, BECs share many properties with
superfluid helium, they have never been seen to share
the existence of roton excitations which are present in
helium. Superfluid helium is close to becoming a solid.
The roton minimum is a consequence of enhanced density
fluctuations at the reciprocal lattice vector of
the stillborn solid. Thus rotons have not been observed
in BECs in atomic traps since they are not near a solid
phase, but if they are tuned near a transition to a Mott
insulating phase, a roton minimum will develop at a
reciprocal lattice vector of the lattice. Equivalently,
a peak in the structure factor will appear at such a
wave vector. The smallness of the roton gap or the
largeness of the structure factor peak are experimental
signatures of the proximity to the Mott transition.
Laughlin’s group has also done some work on
metal-insulator transitions. Specifically, the work was
motivated by V2O3
and f-electron systems which have phase diagrams in
which a line of first order metal-insulator transition
ends at a critical point above which the two phases are
indistinguishable. Bob Laughlin's Gossamer technique was
extended to show that the Gossamer metal in a single
band model will describe a metallic phase that becomes
arbitrarily hard to differentiate from an insulator as
one turns the Coulomb correlations up. Thus one can go
continuously from the metal to the insulator.
Laughlin’s group also has done some work on quantum
criticality that should be published this year. In
collaboration with Jan Zaanen, they have an article on
spin-orbit coupling and interesting quantum interference
effects that will also be published in this period. The
Doniach group expects to continue work on the relation
between superconductivity and electron correlations in
intercalated graphite. Recent work on superconductivity
in doped graphite intercalated compounds has suggested
that, despite theoretical work to model this by
conventional electron phonon coupling BCS theory, these
theories have been unable to explain why different
intercalates have
very different Tc’s.
Tc
spans at least one order of magnitude when going through
different intercalates and it is believed possible to
study the relative effects of t-J correlation coupling
versus electron-phonon coupling on these various Tc’s.
The Doniach group has been focusing on looking at
electron correlations in graphite. Although this has
traditionally been considered in the context of band
theory, recent experiments by Kopelevich and
collaborators show strong evidence of a semi-metal -
insulator transition in applied magnetic fields of order
1 kG. The experimentalists found that a scaling relation
suggested by Das and Doniach in 2001 for the
superconductor – “bose metal” state of thin
filmsuperconductors also applies to the graphite data.
The effects of correlations in graphite have been
studied using a t-J model, following ideas proposed by
Baskaran for the superconductor MgB2.
2. Magnetic Materials Research
J. Stöhr, H. Siegmann, H. Ohldag, Y. Acremann
The general goal of this program is to develop new
techniques and approaches for the study of modern
magnetic materials in the form of thin films,
multilayers and nanostructures and explore the origin of
magnetic phenomena associated with such materials.
Work has continued on the phenomenon of
exchange bias
by means of X-ray microscopy and spectroscopy. In
particular, soft X-ray dichroism absorption spectroscopy
was used to investigate
the direction of interfacial exchange coupling in a
ferromagnetic / antiferromagnetic Co/FeF2 bilayer. This system behaves quite differently from
conventional exchange bias and, depending on sample
preparation, it can exhibit either positive or negative
exchange bias. Two different kinds of
interfacial uncompensated Fe moments were found in FeF2.
A smaller pinned portion couples antiparallel to the
ferromagnet and can lead to positive or negative
exchange bias depending on the size of the cooling
field. A larger portion couples more strongly and
parallel to the ferromagnet. It
increases the degree of antiferromagnetic order in FeF2
near the interface and plays an important role in the
observed coercivity increase at high temperatures. The
work was recently published: H. Ohldag, H. Shi, E.
Arenholz, D. Lederman and J. Stöhr,
Phys. Rev. Lett.
96,
027203 (2006).
The program on ultrafast magnetic switching with
electron beams and the program on lensless magnetic
imaging with X-rays, reported last years, have now been
funded separately as part of the Stanford Ultrafast
Science Center (PULSE) and the work is reported under
that program.
A new subprogram has started, based on the exploration
of new ways of exciting magnetic materials by ultrafast
magnetic field pulses. Rather than using electron beams
ultrafast laser pulses have been explored for launching
fast and strong current pulses. The idea is to generate
ultrafast magnetic field pulses by current flow through
a strip-line, as illustrated in Figure 1. The current
pulse is triggered by an ultrafast laser which either
opens an electro-optical (Auston) switch or creates
ultrafast photoemission into vacuum on one side of the
stripline which is grounded on the other side. Such a
scheme has the advantage of being compatible with
ultrafast X-ray imaging.
Figure 1. Arrangement for generating short and strong
current pulses traveling down a strip line. In the upper
picture the current pulse is generated by a
photoconductive switch, in the lower picture by a
photoemission pulse.
The scheme illustrated in Figure 1 using laser pulse
probe experiments will be explored and will characterize
the achievable pulse length and field strength. Samples
will be fabricated with our new magnetic thin film
deposition system and by use of lithographic
manufacturing techniques.
The design of a scanning transmission X-ray microscope
for BL13 at SSRL will also continue.
3. Scientific and Educational Gateway Program
A. Nilsson, A. Mehta and R. R. Chianelli
This continuing, joint effort with the University of
Texas at El Paso (UTEP) serves both the Mexican-American
and Mexican communities in undergraduate and graduate
education by engaging student scholars in science and
engineering research programs at all levels. The program
provides travel support for Mexican-American and Mexican
students and supporting faculty, science and
technological support by an SSRL scientific staff
member, who also assists participants in beam line
operations and laboratory facilities use, and a
scientific staff member at UTEP, who develops and
implements computational tools and software for analysis
of synchrotron data. These staff members train students
in methods of data reduction and analysis and, jointly
with SSRL staff scientists, develop collaboratory tools
for remote access to instrumentation and data measured
at SSRL. This program has been quite effective, as shown
by the number of UTEP students participating in
FY2001-2005 (almost 50 students). These students and
staff underwent training and carried out experiments on
existing SSRL peer-reviewed proposals coordinated across
five separate beam lines. The students continue to
enhance their training by taking highly successful
proposal writing classes at UTEP (Chianelli). SSRL staff
work closely with the UTEP faculty and staff to train
and support the new students and their research efforts.
Part of the period in FY2005 saw the synchrotron
start-up for the now successfully completed SPEAR3
upgrade. In addition, an electrical accident further
delayed the schedule. However, this allowed time for the
students to concentrate on data analysis with the help
of SSRL and UTEP staff. Progress during this period was
excellent with many students and faculty further
developing their proficiency in the use of synchrotron
techniques and producing publications based on previous
collected data. Several students achieved in-depth
understanding of synchrotron radiation and its
application by attending the Stanford-Berkeley Summer
School.
The level of synchrotron related skills increased
substantially for both the students and faculty, which
will be reflected by refereed publications and meeting
presentations of the group. Particularly skills were
improved in the areas of SAXS and carbon edge XANES.
Progress was made in six core areas in FY2005; (1) The
Chianelli group continued to address structure/function
relations in transition metal sulfide (TMS)
hydrodesulfurization (HDS) nanocatalysts. The first
“Gateway” Ph.D. (Myriam Perez) graduated and accepted a
post-doctoral position at SSRL; (2) Diffraction studies
on Maya Blue demonstrated that the pigment is a surface
complex of the indigodye with palygorskite clay; (3)
Data analysis on both the SAXS and WAXS data from
asphaltenes, crude oils from Mexico and Venezuela and
TMS catalysts was completed; (4) The Gardea group
continued to investigate the metal binding properties of
the “hyperaccumulators”; (5) The Pingitore group
continued to study trace elements in human bone. The
incorporation of Sr, Zn, Pb,
etc.
in human bone is a topic that impacts archaeology,
nuclear waste/terrorism, biomedicine, and environmental
pollution. All of these projects yielded significant
publications in 2005 and in press for 2006.
The SPEAR3 installation allowed time to develop the full
scientific impact of the program. This is shown by the
significant increase in the demonstrated impact of
synchrotron studies on the scientific understanding of
the problems discussed above. Students and faculty are
well trained to participate in “bringing on line” the
new SPEAR3 experiments and testing the new significant
capabilities.
Approximately 60 students will have been involved in
synchrotron programs at SSRL involving multiple
techniques, diffraction (SAXS and WAXS), scattering
techniques including anomalous dispersion scattering,
XAFS (hard and soft X-ray) and protein crystallography.
Many of these students will become a regular part of the
synchrotron user community and some will have
synchrotron use become a major part of their careers.
Many these students will have obtained experience at
other DOE facilities. Up to four students will have
completed or nearly finished a Gateway Ph.D. and become
full members of the synchrotron community. Several
faculty members at UTEP and related Mexican institutions
will have become new synchrotron users. Major scientific
progress will have been reported from the Gateway
program as discussed above. The progress will be of such
quality that the program will not only have made a major
impact on training minority scientists but the students
will have produced significant and competitive
scientific contributions.
4. Novel Materials and Model Systems for the Study of
Correlated Phenomena
I.R. Fisher, M.R. Beasley, T.H. Geballe, M. Greven,
N. Barisic, G. Chabot-Couture, A.S. Erickson, G. Koster,
L. Litvak, Y. Matsushita, N. Ru, P. SanGiorgio, K.Y.
Shin, G. Yu, X. Zhao, X. Zhou
This program directly addresses scientific questions at
the heart of understanding correlated electron behavior
in complex materials. This work explores the conditions
of occurrence and mechanisms behind these effects, and
examines the consequences for bulk properties and
collective phenomena. The approach is to identify and
synthesize model systems that enable exploration of
particular interactions in isolation. The essence of the
proposed research therefore lies in the design, growth
and characterization of novel materials.
The original title of this subtask was “Nanoscale
ordering in complex oxides: model systems for local
probes.” The title was updated during the recent renewal
to better reflect the focus of our current research.
Negative-U Impurities --Over
the course of the last three years a multistep synthesis
route has
been established to produce high-quality single crystals
of the unusual superconductor (Pb1-xTlx)Te,
and work has gone forward on detailed measurements to
characterize the thermodynamic, transport and
spectroscopic properties of these samples. The Tl
impurities appear to act as negative-U centers in this
material, and this research explores the role that these
impurities play in both the superconducting and normal
state properties. Early measurements established that a
critical concentration of Tl impurities is required to
cause superconductivity in PbTe. For Tl concentrations
beyond this critical value the Fermi level appears to be
pinned, such that the Tl impurities act in a
self-compensating manner. It seems that the
superconductivity is intimately linked to the presence
of a mixed Tl valence, the presence of which also is
reflected in the normal state transport of the material.
In particular, during FY2005 evidence was found for a
charge Kondo effect associated with degenerate valence
states of the Tl impurities. This observation, supports
the notion of an electronic pairing mechanism in
superconducting Tl-doped PbTe,
perhaps accounting for the unusually high Tc
value. Ongoing research seeks to further investigate this
effect in Tl-doped PbTe and related materials, testing
various predictions of the theoretical models that have
been proposed.
In FY006, the superconducting properties of Tl-doped
PbTe have been explored in more detail. Heat capacity
measurements for the highest Tl concentrations indicate
that the superconducting
anomaly is close to the BCS result (ΔC/γTc
~ 1.43), which within the charge Kondo model would imply
that the renormalized electrons are indeed participating
in the superconductivity. However, this quantity appears
to show a marked decrease as the impurity concentration
decreases, the origin of which effect is uncertain and
warrants further investigation. Additional insight can
be expected from a close collaboration with C. Gough and
E. M. Forgan (Birmingham, UK) exploring the penetration
depth via microwave conductivity and muon spin rotation.
Initial experiments from early this year indicate that
the T-dependence of the superfluid density is close to
BCS predictions, but with some unusual field dependence.
The continuing normal state magnetotransport
measurements show an unexpected trend towards a linear
T-dependence of the resistivity that we are continuing
to study. These data are currently being modeled by J.
Schmalian (Ames Laboratory) and P. Coleman (Rutgers) in
terms of a pair-diffusion process associated with the
negative-U properties of the Tl-impurities. Initial
EXAFS measurements (in collaboration with
F. Bridges, UCSC) are suggestive of two Tl-Te distances,
consistent with the proposed disproportionation, but are
limited in resolution due to the proximity of a nearby
Pb absorption edge. Experiments are also planned at the
NHMFL Microkelvin Laboratory (with Yoon Seuk Lee,
U. Florida) to look for reentrant behavior at low
temperatures, a key prediction of Schmalian’s charge
Kondo model. Additional external collaborations will
probe the effect of pressure on the superconducting and
normal state properties (S. Brown, UCLA), the optical
conductivity (Z. Schlesinger, UCSC) and core level
spectroscopy (C. Fadley, UCSD).
Charge-Density Waves in Layered Rare Earth Tellurides
-- We recently identified the
layered rare earth (R) tellurides RTe3
and RTe2
as model systems to study Fermi surface reconstruction
in incommensurate CDW compounds, a topic that has
significant bearing on current questions in the field of
cuprates and other strongly correlated oxides. These are
particularly attractive model systems because (a) the
electronic structure is especially simple and the band
filling can be tuned by chemical substitution; (b) the
CDW gap is large and can be measured by a variety of
powerful techniques; (c) we can explore the consequences
of the CDW formation on the magnetic properties of the
material; and (d) we are able to grow high-quality
single crystals, enabling sensitive probes of the
Fermi surface including dHvA and ARPES, and real space
probes including STM.
Initial angle resolved photoemission experiments in
collaboration with Z.X. Shen clearly revealed the CDW
gap, showing gapped and ungapped regions of the Fermi
surface. Our ongoing
experiments further explored the Fermi surface nesting
and CDW formation in both RTe3.
Further
experiments probing the FS reconstruction in RTe3
were conducted by a student supported by thisgrant
during an extended visit to A.P. Mackenzie’s research
group in St. Andrews, Scotland. These measurements
revealed multiple frequencies all of which vary with
angle according to 1/cos(theta), consistent with minimal
z-axis dispersion. The measurements are currently being
compared with ARPES data with the aim of fully
determining the reconstructed FS. Other experiments have
been performed at SSRL, following award of beam time.
Initial high-resolution diffraction experiments have
revealed an extremely well-ordered modulated structure
with minimal harmonic content. These measurements are
continuing with the ultimate goal of finding a model for
the atomic displacements in the CDW state, and hence
determining whether the material consists of short
regions of commensurate modulations with regular
discommensurations, or is indeed a truly incommensurate
structure.
Experiments at SSRL have established that the CDW in RTe3
has remarkably little harmonic content. Work is
currently in process to model the atomic displacements
in an effort to differentiate between a truly
incommensurate distortion and a modulation consisting of
a dense array of discommensurations. Further diffraction
experiments were planned to follow the T-dependence of
the CDW wave-vector, motivated in part by theoretical
models of S. Kivelson (Stanford) predicting a possible
phase transition between unidirectional (stripe) and
bidirectional (checkerboard) order. Additional
experiments and analysis will finalize our dHvA study,
while magnetotransport measurements will pursue our
recent observation of superzone gap formation in
the heavy rare earth members of the series (i.e.
an additional gapping of the FS at TN).
Work has
also continued to explore the role of Te vacancies in
RTe2-x
in determining the optimal nesting wave-vectors and
resulting CDW modulation in this single-layer variant.
Most excitingly, there is
now confidence the alternating single and double layer
compound R2Te5,
intermediate between the
single layer RTe2
and bilayer RTe3
compounds has been successfully synthesized. Experiments
are probing how band filling affects the CDW formation
in this family of compounds, providing a useful window
on the role of dimensionality (stripe vs checkerboard)
in CDW systems. Numerous internal and external
collaborations continue to probe other physical
properties of these materials, including STM (A.
Kapitulnik, Stanford), optical conductivity (L.
DeGiorgi, ETH, Zürich), NMR
(V. Brouet, Université de Paris Sud, France) and
positron annihilation (S. Dugdale, Bristol, UK).
Ferromagnetism in the Mott Insulator Ba2NaOsO6
-- The interplay between orbital and spin degrees of
freedom can play a pivotal role in many correlated
electron effects. Perhaps the clearest example of this
is to be found in ferromagnetic Mott insulators – a
rarified and unusual class of materials. In a single
band Hubbard model, hopping between adjacent sites leads
to anantiferromagnetic ground state. However, orbital
degeneracy can favor ferromagnetic exchange due to the
additional energy that can be gained from Hund's rule
coupling of electrons in two different orbitals. In such
a case, the appearance of ferromagnetism is thought to
be accompanied by a complex form of anti-ferro orbital
order, the precise nature of which depends strongly on
details of the specific lattice and material. This is an
exciting and topical area in correlated electron
physics. However, there are precious few candidate
materials. Furthermore, those that have been studied
belong exclusively to the 3d transition series.
Ba2NaOsO6
presents a wonderful opportunity to study the interplay
of orbital and spin ordering in the unusual environment
of a 5d1
ferromagnet. A method has recently been determined to
grow relatively large single crystals of this material
that enable a host of exciting experiments. Initial
thermodynamic and transport measurements, performed
early in FY2006, demonstrate that this material is
indeed a ferromagnetic Mott insulator, but with an
ordered moment that is substantially less than 1 μB
(i.e.,
the ordered state consists of a complicated spin
structure with a net ferromagnetic moment). The reason
for this is becoming evident. At room temperature,
Ba2NaOsO6
occupies an undistorted double-perovskite structure, in
which the OsO6
coordination polyhedra are neither rotated with respect
to the lattice, nor distorted from a perfect octahedral
symmetry. In this case, the three t2g orbitals are indeed degenerate, and ferromagnetic
exchange can be anticipated. However, the FCC lattice
cannot be decorated with three "color" orbitals in such
a way that each site always has nearest neighbors of a
different color. For adjacent sites of the same color
the superexchange is perforce antiferromagnetic. Hence,
in the absence of any additional structural phase
transition, it can be anticipated that the resulting
ground state of
Ba2NaOsO6
is a complex mixture of spin and orbital order, with a
strong ferromagnetic
component, but which falls short of 1
μB.
An active proposal is in place with the Advanced
PhotonSource (together with Z. Islam, APS, ANL) to study
the spin and orbital ordering in this compound later in
the year. Other ongoing experiments will probe the
high-field magnetization (with L. Balicas, NHMFL),
exploring the possibility of a metamagnetic transition
to the fully saturated state.
Electronic Inhomogeneities in Correlated Electron
Materials --
One of the goals of this programis to synthesize model
systems for the study of nanoscale electronic
inhomogeneities that result from the coulomb
interactions in correlated electronic materials, and
ultimately to study these inhomogeneities using scanning
probes. Toward this end, thin films of the Mott
insulator CuO have been grown, in which such nanoscale
inhomogeneities have been previously reported. This is
perhaps the simplest conceivable copper oxide related to
the high temperature cuprate superconductors. Epitaxial
thin films of stable monoclinic CuO have been grown
previously on MgO substrates. More recently CuO has been
grown epitaxially with square symmetry in the plane (i.e.,
either cubic or tetragonal overall). The composition is
confirmed by UPS spectra taken
in-situ
in an adjacent chamber. The structure has been confirmed
using
in-situ
RHEED and byPhoto-Electron Diffraction. Ion-beam
assisted deposition (IBAD) has been tried to further
enhance our ability to get a cubic structure, but this
has not so far been successful, due presumably to
differential sputtering of oxygen and cupper. Very
recently, it has also shown that CuO can be grown using
Pulsed Laser Deposition. The detailed properties of
films grown by these two methods now need to be
compared.
In parallel with this effort, thin films of ZrO2
have been deposited using pulsed laser deposition(PLD)
for use as high-K dielectrics for field-effect doping
applications. The student working on this project has
left the university. In light of this, focus will revert
to the CuO work and this part of the project will not be
continuing.
A square-planar (rock salt) form of CuO has now been
deposited successfully and physical study of these films
is being pursued. Standard transport and optical
measurements are being carried out, and various scanning
probes are being applied in collaboration with
colleagues here at Stanford. These include Scanning Hall
probes, MFM, STM and scanning potentiometry to look for
inhomogeneities. In addition, on the materials side,
studies will begin on approaches to dope these films.
This might be done through introducing oxygen deficiency
or by using strongly electropositive (or negative)
over-layers.
Superconductivity and Magnetism: Pair Density Waves and
SrRuO3 --Studies
of the superconductor/ferromagnetic proximity have drawn
a remarkable level of interest, primarily because it is
proving to be an effective model system for the study of
the interaction between superconductivity and magnetism.
One of the most striking predictions from theory is the
existence of decaying pair density waves in the
ferromagnetic side of an SF proximity bilayer due to the
exchange field in the F material. Evidence for this
effect is mixed. In order to get more detailed
information regarding SF proximity structures, in
collaboration with the group of Kookrin Char at Seoul
National University, tunneling density of states studies
are in progress on the F side of Nb/permalloy SF
bilayers as a function of the thickness of the F layer.
It is found that the striking result that the tunneling
density of states as a function of thickness (viewed as
deviations from the normal density of states) is of
constant form with amplitude that scales exponentially
over four orders of magnitude as a function of the F
layer thickness. No evidence for pair density
oscillations was found. More recently, a detailed
comparison of these results with the available
theory has been carried out. It is found that the theory
can account for these data only if patently unreasonable
values are used of the exchange field and the spin-flip
scattering rate. This work has now been accepted for
publication. One possible reason for this serious
discrepancy is that we are using very strong
ferromagnets whereas the theory assumes weak magnetism.
In order to clarify the situation, a second strong
ferromagnet (Ni) is presently being studied for the F
material.
Thin films of SrRuO3,
a rare example of a 4d itinerant ferromagnet continue o
be deposited and studied. With the group of Lior Klein,
the magneto-transport in SrRuO3
is being examined to test recent theories of the effect
of the Berry phase in magnetic systems. We did not
confirm the predictions. Studies also continue of
various physical properties of the films including spin
accumulation at domain walls during electric transport,
the magnetic anisotropy of the material and the
superconducting properties of Nb/SrRuO3
SF hybrids. In SF hybrids there is only magnetic coupling
between the S and F layers (i.e. there is no proximity
effect coupling).
Given
present results on the tunneling density of states on
Nb/permalloy SF proximity bilayers, it is very important
to study other F materials to see if these results are
universal or specific to permalloy. Studies with Ni as
the F material were mentioned above. The next obvious
step would be to move systematically to lower exchange
fields. Following others, the Ni-Cu alloy system will be
used. Scanning Hall probe studies of these bilayers will
also be carried out to establish directly the
orientation and spatial homogeneity (or not) of the
magnetization of the F layers.
As was mentioned last year, it is also planned to use
the
in situ
FTIR system to study the optical
conductivity of SrRuO3
at high temperatures. Lower temperature measurements
carried out by us with Zack Schlesinger at UCSC showed
that a coulomb-like pseudo-gap appears to open at low
frequencies as temperature increases. This seems to be
part and parcel of the bad metal behavior of this
material (i.e.,
increasing resistivity with increasing temperature
beyond the Ioffe-Regal limit).Recent theories of highly
incoherent electrons using dynamical mean-field theory
predict such a gap should open. Clearly these
predictions need to be tested.
Advanced Superconductors --The
mercury-based materials HgBa2Can-1O2n+2+δ
are model high-temperature superconductors due to their
relatively simple structure, because they appear to be
least affected by chemical disorder, and because of
their record superconducting transition
temperatures (e.g.,
for n = 3, Tc
= 134 K at ambient pressure and 164 K at 31 GPa).
Consequently, these materials are the most desirable
high-temperature superconductors for experimental study.
Comparison with results for lower-Tc
materials will eventually allow us to separate
materials-specific properties from properties shared by
all superconducting cuprates. However, the synthesis of
this homologous series has remained a serious challenge
until recently, and rather few experiments have been
done on the Hg family of superconductors. In a major
breakthrough, we succeeded in growing single crystals of
Hg1201 (n=1) as large as 50 mm3,
more than two orders of magnitude larger than the
previous world record. Neutron